HII loses $708M Navy contract after Salary-dot-com check inflates its bid

Gettyimages.com/Kanok Sulaiman

Find opportunities — and win them.

The Navy could not see HII’s in-house pay data, so the service branch used the commercial website to evaluate labor rates and that added another $156 million to the company’s proposal.

HII has lost a $708 million incumbent contract with the Navy, in large part because the Navy could not evaluate realism of the wages quoted by the company for unfilled positions.

The Navy had no access to an internal system HII used to establish the wages, according to the Government Accountability Office's denial of an HII protest that was unsealed Monday.

HII and Amentum were among five companies vying for the Navy Integrated Training Environment II contract that covers operations and maintenance for the fleet’s live, virtual and constructive training ranges.

The Navy went to Salary.com to evaluate the labor rates in HII’s bid. Based on that analysis, the service branch increased the evaluated cost of HII’s bid to $156 million.

That meant the HII evaluated price came in at $12.8 million above Amentum, the company that ultimately won the contract. The Navy also increased Amentum’s proposed cost by $115 million, but the final evaluated cost was still lower than HII’s.

HII went to GAO and challenged the use of Salary.com to analyze the realism of its proposed labor rates. But GAO pointed to the solicitation, where the Navy said it could use salary databases in ithe cost realism review.

HII also argued that if the Navy used Salary.com, then it should have worked with different percentile than the 50th percentile, or median, it chose. The percentile HII wanted is redacted in the decision.

The Navy also argued that the percentile HII wanted it to use did not exist in Salary.com, so the Navy could not use HII's preferred percentile even if it wanted to do.

HII also challenged the Navy’s rejection of its location-based adjustments, which lowered its rates for positions in cheaper markets. The Navy countered that Salary.com’s rates already accounted for location, so accepting HII’s reductions would have counted the discount twice. GAO agreed with the Navy.

The increase in its evaluated cost wiped out any advantage HII may have had over Amentum. The Navy rated Amentum’s technical proposal as “outstanding” compared to HII’s “good.”

The Navy also scored Amentum’s past performance as “substantial confidence,” while HII was scored with “satisfactory confidence.”

The best-value decision for the Navy was relatively easy. The source selection official said Amentum was a “clear and unambiguous better value,” according to the GAO decision.

HII also challenged how the Navy evaluated its technical proposal, but GAO said those arguments did not include enough specifics to warrant a higher rating.

GAO did not decide whether the Navy erred on past performance. GAO said HII was not harmed because even if they had earned the top rating, the bid would still have been rated lower on technical and cost more than Amentum.