Forget the election. Your recompete is already being decided.

Gettyimages.com/Abraham Gonzalez Fernandez
Exceptional CPARS ratings and green gate reviews won’t save incumbents who aren’t capturing what the customer tells them on every call, writes growth expert Nic Coppings.
Someone on the capture team says, “We lost it on price,” and everyone buys the excuse. You held the contract for eight years. Your CPARS ratings were exceptional, and every gate review was green. Then someone reads the debrief, and the room goes quiet.
The award rationale credits the winner with strengths in the exact areas your customer raised on status calls. The winner listened and built a proposal around those problems. Your team was on every one of those calls, but nobody wrote the feedback down, tied it to customer needs, or shared it with capture. So, you answered the RFP as written, and the evaluators rated your approach lower.
YOUR CUSTOMER ALREADY HAS A VIEW OF YOUR TEAM
Every BD meeting this week opened with pipeline worry. Democrats take control of Congress in January, and the continuing resolution ends Dec. 11. Everyone is focused on what has changed.
In reality, nothing has changed in the program office. It has the same mission, the same pain points, and the same view of your team it held before the ballots were counted. Congress and the funding deadline will matter, but the big opportunities in the new year will go to the team that understands the customer best.
Deltek’s fiscal 2027 report shows 15 of the top 20 unrestricted contracts already have an incumbent, and the program office behind each one is deciding now what the next contract will ask for. Most incumbents are sure they know what the customer thinks of them. Hi-Q’s data shows 73% of teams overestimate their relationship strength.
Line up your wins and losses side by side. Price takes the blame, but the customer conversations explain more of the difference. Even when price decides the award, you must know what the customer needs to price it right. Teams who guess end up too high or too low.
THE LOSSES SOUND THE SAME
On the losses, the team thought it knew better than the customer. They made assumptions, walked into every call sure of the answer, and asked questions only to prove it. When the customer described a problem, they had a fix ready before the customer finished the second sentence.
Some brushed off what the customer said. Others stayed heads down on delivery. The proposal was me-too with no real differentiator. Staying quiet with the customer feels safe. It is how incumbents lose contracts they should have kept.
THE WINS SOUND DIFFERENT
On the wins, the team knew what was affecting the mission going forward, how the funding was shifting, and who owned the change. They did the basics on every call, not only when a contract was on the table. They cared about the customer’s success, understood the why, listened, asked follow-up questions, and shared the intel with the team. Their bid answered the customer’s problems.
QUALITY IS NOT VALUE
A customer will rate you exceptional on quality and still have no idea what you did for the mission. Quality is what you delivered. Value is what the customer says about it when you’re not in the room.
THE 22-POINT GAP IS NOT PRICE
Deltek’s 2023 Clarity Government Contracting Scorecard put the average recompete win rate at 58% and high performers at 80%. At the average, you lose more than four of every 10 recompetes. In my experience, the gap is the distance between the quality you deliver and the value the customer sees. Your gate reviews will keep showing green until the debrief says otherwise.
NOBODY TAUGHT THEM
Nobody taught your program managers how to gather customer intel, which intel matters, or how to pass it to capture. You measure them on deliverables, schedule, costs, and a clean CPARS, and almost never on whether they bring back intel capture needs. Then you expect growth to show up anyway.
WHAT WINNERS DO ON THE CALLS YOU ALREADY HAVE
The incumbents who keep their work penetrate the account. More of their people meet with more of the customer’s people, because growth is everyone’s job.
- They ask what is changing. Every quarter, the PM asks the customer what has changed for the mission, the funding, and the politics, and writes down the answer in the customer’s words.
- They put those words in front of leadership. The answer goes in the program review next to costs and schedule, and a blank box counts as a risk.
- They widen access. The COR, the government PM, and the deputy who will write the next requirement have each heard from more than one person on your team in the last 90 days. If one PM holds every customer relationship, you don’t own the account. Your PM does.
RUN THE REVIEW BEFORE YOU LOSE
Pick a must-win recompete and ask the PM one question. If someone asked the customer’s program manager tomorrow why the work should continue, what would she say about you? Most PMs I ask answer with the CPARS score. A few answer with what the customer told them last month. Those few have winning relationships. Most have social ones.
A social relationship is friendly: the customer takes the call and says the work is going well. A winning relationship produces intel: the customer tells you what is changing, what worries them, and why your work matters. A customer relationship score separates the two by scoring what the customer shares, not how pleasant the calls are.
Test your must-win recompete with three questions. If you don’t know the answers, you have a social relationship.
- Who decides? Name the two or three stakeholders who shape the next award.
- What will they say? Write it down in their words, not yours.
- When did we last hear it? If nobody on your team knows, the answer is never.
Someone will run the win-loss review on your must-win recompete. Either you run it now, while the outcome is still open, or the customer hands you the answer in the debrief, too late to use it.
Nic Coppings is a senior partner at Hi-Q Group and creator of the Winning Relationships® BD Masterclass. An advisor to leaders at many Top 100 GovCon firms, Nic changes how BD, capture, and delivery teams engage federal buyers, shifting conversations from transactional pitches to strategic partnerships and raising win rates. With more than 20 years of B2B and GovCon experience, he helps executive teams protect recompetes and win new work. Connect with him at ncoppings@hi-qgroup.com before your next major pursuit.